Risk Assessment of Mamak Dam Based on The ICOLD Modification Method and Risk Index Method
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31305/rrijm.2024.v09.n04.008Keywords:
Risk Index, ICOLD, Mamak Dam, Dam SafetyAbstract
The Mamak Dam has the risk of damage and the need for evacuation at an extreme downstream level. Risk considerations are based on the potential natural disasters of the dam, the impact of dam failure, design loads, and safety coefficients. The Risk Index method results in a score with parameters such as spillway capacity adequacy, safety factor adequacy against slopes, disaster factor (hazard), and all parameters analyzed to determine the Dam Safety Index (Idam). The drawback of the Risk Index method is neglecting downstream failure analysis. The ICOLD modification method for parameters is the same as the Risk Index method, but the ICOLD method considers downstream analysis. The modification involves adding parameters, such as the condition of the dam slope cover layer, based on the Mamak Dam Large Inspection results. In the Risk Index method, the Idam calculation value is 262.5. The total risk index value for Mamak Dam is 51.73, with a dam safety value of 92.337. In the ICOLD method, the Idam calculation value is 245, with a total risk index value for Mamak Dam of 48.28 and a Dam Safety value of 92.848. Meanwhile, using the Modified ICOLD method, the Idam calculation value is 245, with a total risk index value for Mamak Dam of 49.93 and a Dam Safety value of 92.603. Based on these results, the Dam Safety value with the Modified ICOLD method has decreased but still falls within the satisfactory classification (>75). Therefore, it can be concluded that Mamak Dam is currently at a safe level against normal loads and extraordinary loads (design floods and design earthquakes).
References
Andersen GR, Chouinard LE, Bouvier CJ, Back WE. 2001. Ranking Procedure on Maintenance Tasks for Monitoring of Embankment Dams. Journal of Geotechnology and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 125 (4): 88-96
Azdan, Donny and Samekto, Candra . 2008. The Critical Condition of Dams in Indonesia. Journal of the National Seminar on Big Dams in Surabaya 2-3 July 2008.
Public Works Department. 2000. Procedures for Quality Control of Embankment Dams. Pd. T-17-2000-03. Minister of Public Works Decree No: 08/KPTS/T/2000
Department of Settlements and Regional Infrastructure. 2004. Construction and Building Guidelines: Stability analysis of embankment type dams.
Department of Public Works and Regional Infrastructure. 2003. Kasian Dam Safety Guidelines.
Directorate General of Water Resources. 2016. Dam Performance Assessment Guidelines. Jakarta.
Directorate General of Irrigation. (1998). Guidelines for Preparing Emergency Action Plans, Decree of the Director General of Water Resources, Number 94/KPTS/A/1998, dated 30 July 1998. Jakarta. Public Works Department.
Hadihardjaja IK. 2006. Reliability Analysis of Optimal Operation of the Citarum Cascade Reservoir to Meet Raw Water Needs. Journal of Design and Construction. 5(1): 21-35
Ishbaev, Avazbek. Bogor Agricultural Institute. 2015. Evaluation of Dam Safety Based on Risk Index at Jatiluhur Dam. Bogor
Najoan TF, Soetijono C. 2002. Static Slope Stability Analysis Method for Embankment Type Dams in the Water Building Series. Center for Water Resources Research and Development. ISBN 979-3197-20-X.
[PUPR Ministerial Regulation] Ministry of Public Works and Public Housing. 2015. Regulation of the Minister of Public Works and Public Housing of the Republic of Indonesia Number 27/Prt/M/2015 concerning Dams.
Rachdian Eko Suprapto, Japparusidik, Sriyana, Kresna WS. 2021. Pelaparado Dam Risk Assessment Based on the Modified ICOLD Method and Risk Index Method. West Nusa Tenggara.
Dam Hall Work Unit, Ministry of Public Works, 2008. Appendices A To J. Project Implementation Plan For Dam Operational Improvement And Safety Project (DOISP). Smec International Pty Ltd.
United States. Bureau of Reclamation. 1987. Design of Small Dams. United States.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0).
